Maybe it is just me but if I was a buyer in today's real estate market and I heard that Congress was trying to increase the $8,000 first time buyer tax credit to $15,000 and include all home buyers, I would seriously consider holding off on making a purchase. Why you ask? Well, there are many different reasons and they all stem from the uncertainty of what Congress will eventually do, if anything.
Congress is notorious for floating out many different versions of a bill and then watering down one of them in order to get it passed by both the Senate and the House of Representatives and then get signed by the President. This causes many great ideas and sound solutions to become ineffective and a waste of time.
We don't have to look any further than the current $8,000 tax credit. At one point it was a $15,000 credit that would have been available to all buyers. But that bold, decisive bill that would have had a tremendously larger impact on home sales was weakened and become the current credit that has already had
one major change and is set to expire on December 1st. And there is no sign that the credit has done anything to improve the housing market.
So now they are considering either extending the current credit for another year, increasing the size to $15,000, adding a $3,000 credit for refinances and/or letting all home buyers get the credit. And there is no indication of whether or not the new limits and credits will be retroactive and how far back they will go.
The last credit was retroactive to Jan 1st when it was signed into law as part of the stimulus package in the middle of February. How far back they make the next credit is anyones guess. And that is the problem. What if they pass the bill and don't make it retroactive? What if the actually bill gets debated and changed and watered down again and doesn't get passed until the fall? What then?
What should a prospective buyer do if they want the full $15,000 credit and want to be guaranteed they get it if in fact that is what Congress passes? They have to wait and see. That is the only way to guarantee you get the credit because no one knows what will happen. The people that bought a home last year have to pay back their tax credit because they didn't wait.
Congress cannot make swift, decisive moves that will help the economy. Congress doesn't do what is right, they do what will get them re-elected. They need to answer to special interests, not constituents because special interests give them the money to get re-eleted. Congress can't make hard decisions and instead they have partisan battles and pass bills with partial solutions that are ineffective.
And this latest battle over the tax credit will showcase Congress at its finest, working to confuse the public, change the rules, cut some people out and create another finger pointing debacle. Much like the TARP that didn't buy any toxic assets and a stimulus bill that doesn't stimulate.
I ask again, is Congress trying to undermine a real estate recovery? I say yes.
UPDATE: I will be at a function this Friday with Rep. Frank Wolf (R), the congressman for my district here in Northern Virginia. I will try and corner him and ask him some pointed questions regarding the tax credit and efforts to help the housing recovery instead of continuing to create indecision in the minds of the public.
Recent Comments